At a Glance
- Best Overall Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil – 600 mg of EPA and DHA per serving, the most on our list, with only a small amount of vitamin A.Review ↓
- Best Budget NOW Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg – a simple one-softgel serving at the lowest cost per serving we found.Review ↓
- Best Third-Party Certified Sports Research Wild Alaskan Cod Liver Oil – IFOS certified and MSC certified sustainable, in a fish gelatin softgel.Review ↓
- Best One-a-Day A & D Carlson Cod Liver Oil Gems Super 1000 mg – 600 mcg of vitamin A and 10 mcg of vitamin D in one softgel.Review ↓
- Best Simple Formula Nutricost Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg – cod liver oil in a plain softgel with nothing else added.Review ↓
- Best High-Omega-3 Value Micro Ingredients Cod Liver Oil 2,000 mg – 500 mg of omega-3 per serving at the lowest cost per gram of omega-3.Review ↓
- Best Mini Softgel Nature’s Craft Icelandic Cod Liver Oil – small 500 mg softgels that buyers find easy to swallow.Review ↓
The Short Answer: The best cod liver oil capsules give you omega-3s along with a moderate amount of vitamin A, so you get the benefits without getting close to the upper limit13. Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil is our top pick: 3 softgels give 600 mg of EPA and DHA but only about 6% of the vitamin A upper limit. On a budget, NOW Cod Liver Oil gives 170 mg of EPA and DHA plus vitamins A and D in one softgel.
On this page
- Do You Actually Need Cod Liver Oil?
- Find Your Match
- How Many Softgels Reach the Vitamin A Upper Limit?
- Cod Liver Oil Capsules Compared
- The 7 Best Cod Liver Oil Capsules, Reviewed
- Products We Didn’t Recommend
- Evidence Scorecard
- How to Take Cod Liver Oil for Best Results
- What to Expect and When
- Safety, Side Effects & Drug Interactions
- Food First: Where Else to Get These Nutrients
- How to Choose a Cod Liver Oil Supplement
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Final Verdict
Cod liver oil differs from regular fish oil because it naturally contains vitamins A and D. That is useful if your diet is low in both, but it also means you can’t simply take more softgels to get more omega-3. Vitamin A from supplements builds up in the body, and too much can harm the liver and bones and cause birth defects in pregnancy1.
We screened 16 cod liver oil softgel listings and compared labels for 7 on omega-3 per serving, vitamin A and D amounts, testing, other ingredients and cost. Every product is ranked by its BFN Score, a relative score within this guide. See our review process for how we score.
Do You Actually Need Cod Liver Oil?
Cod liver oil makes the most sense if you eat little fish and want a small, steady amount of omega-3s with vitamins A and D in one softgel. The Dietary Guidelines advice to eat about 8 ounces of seafood a week works out to roughly 250 mg of EPA and DHA a day3.
Cod liver oil may help if you:
- Rarely eat oily fish and want to top up EPA and DHA3.
- Get little sun or eat few vitamin D foods. Most adults need 15 mcg of vitamin D a day, or 20 mcg after age 702.
- Don’t take a multivitamin that already contains vitamin A.
If you want a high dose of omega-3, for example for high triglycerides, a regular fish oil or a prescription omega-3 is a better fit. The 4 g a day used in triglyceride studies would mean far too much vitamin A from cod liver oil41. Large trials in healthy adults haven’t shown that omega-3 supplements prevent heart attacks overall3.
Who Should Skip It or Ask First
- People who are pregnant or may become pregnant, because too much preformed vitamin A can cause birth defects1.
- Anyone taking a retinoid medicine such as isotretinoin or acitretin, or a multivitamin with vitamin A1.
- People with liver disease, or older adults with low bone density, since long-term high vitamin A intake may affect bones1.
- Anyone on warfarin or another blood thinner, or with surgery coming up3.
- People with a fish allergy.
Find Your Match
| If you… | Consider | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Want the most omega-3 with low vitamin A | Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil | 600 mg EPA + DHA, about 6% of the vitamin A limit |
| Want the lowest cost per softgel | NOW Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg | One softgel, vitamins A and D included |
| Want independent purity certification | Sports Research Wild Alaskan Cod Liver Oil | IFOS and MSC certified |
| Avoid beef gelatin | Sports Research Wild Alaskan Cod Liver Oil | Fish gelatin softgel |
| Want vitamins A and D from one softgel | Carlson Cod Liver Oil Gems Super 1000 mg | 600 mcg A and 10 mcg D |
| Want a plain formula | Nutricost Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg | Cod liver oil, gelatin, glycerin and water |
| Want more omega-3 for the money | Micro Ingredients Cod Liver Oil 2,000 mg | 500 mg omega-3 per serving |
| Have trouble with large pills | Nature’s Craft Icelandic Cod Liver Oil | Mini 500 mg softgels |
| Are pregnant or trying to conceive | Talk to your doctor first | Preformed vitamin A can cause birth defects1 |
How Many Softgels Reach the Vitamin A Upper Limit?
The adult upper limit for preformed vitamin A is 3,000 mcg RAE a day from all sources: supplements, multivitamins, liver and fortified foods1. This table shows how fast each product gets there.
| Product | Vitamin A per Softgel | Labeled Serving | % of Upper Limit per Serving | Softgels to Reach the Upper Limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nordic Naturals | About 63 mcg | 3 softgels (up to 190 mcg) | About 6% | About 47 |
| NOW | 300 mcg | 1 softgel | 10% | 10 |
| Sports Research | 300 mcg | 1 softgel | 10% | 10 |
| Carlson | 600 mcg | 1 softgel | 20% | 5 |
| Nutricost | 750 mcg | 1 softgel | 25% | 4 |
| Micro Ingredients | About 533 mcg | 3 softgels (1,600 mcg) | About 53% | About 6 |
| Nature’s Craft | 750 mcg | 2 softgels (1,500 mcg) | 50% | 4 |
If you also take a multivitamin, add its vitamin A (listed as retinyl palmitate or retinyl acetate) to these numbers. Beta-carotene doesn’t count toward the upper limit1.
Cod Liver Oil Capsules Compared
Scroll sideways to see every column →
| # | Product | Serving | EPA + DHA | Vitamin A | Vitamin D | Purity Testing | Additives | Shell | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nordic Naturals | 3 softgels | 600 mg | Up to 190 mcg (21% DV) | Under 2% DV | Not stated (brand posts certificates of analysis) | Clean | Gelatin | $$$ |
| 2 | NOW | 1 softgel | 170 mg | 300 mcg (33% DV) | 10 mcg (50% DV) | Not stated (brand says it tests in its own labs) | Note: bovine gelatin | Bovine gelatin | $$$ |
| 3 | Sports Research | 1 softgel | 100 mg | 300 mcg (33% DV) | 10 mcg (50% DV) | IFOS certified | Clean | Fish (tilapia) gelatin | $$$ |
| 4 | Carlson | 1 softgel | 180 mg | 600 mcg (67% DV) | 10 mcg (50% DV) | Not stated | Note: bovine gelatin | Bovine gelatin | $$$ |
| 5 | Nutricost | 1 softgel | 170 mg | 750 mcg (83% DV) | 6 mcg (30% DV) | Not stated (brand says third-party tested) | Clean | Gelatin | $$$ |
| 6 | Micro Ingredients | 3 softgels | 466 mg | 1,600 mcg (178% DV) | About 16 mcg (80% DV) | Not stated (brand says third-party tested) | Flag: added retinyl palmitate | Enteric softgel | $$$ |
| 7 | Nature’s Craft | 2 softgels | 180 mg | 1,500 mcg (168% DV) | 12.5 mcg (63% DV) | ISO 17025 lab tested (lab not named) | Flag: added retinyl palmitate | Bovine gelatin | $$$ |
The 7 Best Cod Liver Oil Capsules, Reviewed
#1Best Overall
1. Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil, Lemon
BFN Score9.6/10
$$$Premium60 servings3 softgels per serving
Strongest atEvidence fitWeakest atValue & practicality
Nordic Naturals gives 750 mg of omega-3s per serving, including 600 mg of EPA and DHA, the most on our list. Its vitamin A is low, so you can take a full serving alongside a multivitamin without getting close to the upper limit.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- Arctic cod liver oil (natural triglyceride form)
- Dose per serving
- 3 softgels – omega-3s 750 mg (EPA 240 mg, DHA 360 mg)
- Dose vs. research
- More than twice the roughly 250 mg EPA + DHA a day from 8 oz of seafood a week3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A up to 190 mcg RAE (21% DV, about 6% of the upper limit); vitamin D under 2% DV
- Purity testing
- Not stated on the label (the brand posts third-party certificates of analysis)
- Other ingredients
- gelatin, glycerin, water, natural lemon flavor, d-alpha tocopherol, rosemary extract
- Additives
- Clean
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod); not vegetarian
Clinical Relevance
A full serving supplies more EPA and DHA than most people get from eating fish twice a week3. Because the vitamin A is low, this is the safest product here if you also take a multivitamin or eat liver1. It isn’t a meaningful source of vitamin D, so get that from sun, food or a separate supplement2.
Strengths
- Most EPA and DHA per serving
- Lowest vitamin A on our list
- Lemon flavor and antioxidants added to protect the oil
Limitations
- Highest cost per serving
- 3 softgels per serving
- Almost no vitamin D
Practical Details
Take 3 softgels a day with a meal, or split them between two meals.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who want cod liver oil mainly for omega-3s.
Not forpeople who want a vitamin D source.
Buyer Experience
Buyers say these softgels leave no fishy aftertaste or burps, and many report health benefits and trust the purity.
The main complaint is size: a clear majority of buyers who mention pill size find the softgels large.
vs. NOW Cod Liver Oil
Choose Nordic Naturals for more than three times the EPA and DHA and much less vitamin A. Choose NOW for a lower cost and 10 mcg of vitamin D.
Nutritionist’s Note
Refining can strip much of cod liver oil’s natural vitamin D, so check the label rather than assuming every cod liver oil is a vitamin D source.
Verdict: The best pick if you want cod liver oil for its omega-3s while keeping vitamin A low.
#2Best Budget
2. NOW Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg
BFN Score9.0/10
$$$Budget90 servings1 softgel per serving
Strongest atValue & practicalityWeakest atEvidence fit
NOW gives 1,000 mg of cod liver oil in one softgel, with 170 mg of EPA and DHA, 300 mcg of vitamin A and 10 mcg of vitamin D, at the lowest cost per serving we found.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- cod liver oil
- Dose per serving
- 1 softgel – EPA 70 mg, DHA 100 mg
- Dose vs. research
- Below the roughly 250 mg EPA + DHA a day from seafood advice; 2 softgels get you there3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 300 mcg (10% of the upper limit); vitamin D 10 mcg (50% DV)
- Purity testing
- Not stated (the brand says it tests in its own labs)
- Other ingredients
- softgel (bovine gelatin, glycerin, water)
- Additives
- Note – bovine gelatin
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod); not vegetarian
Clinical Relevance
One softgel covers half the daily vitamin D target for most adults and a third of the vitamin A Daily Value12. Two softgels a day still keep vitamin A at only 20% of the upper limit.
Strengths
- Lowest cost per serving
- Moderate vitamin A
- One softgel per serving
Limitations
- Modest omega-3 per softgel
- Bovine gelatin
- No outside certification
Practical Details
Take 1–2 softgels a day with a meal.
Best For / Not For
Best forbudget buyers who want vitamins A and D with some omega-3.
Not forpeople avoiding beef gelatin.
Buyer Experience
Buyers rate the quality and value highly, and many say the softgels are tasteless with no fishy burps. Several report fewer aches.
Pill size gets mixed reviews: some find it normal, while more say it’s too big to swallow easily. A small group mentions side effects.
vs. Sports Research Wild Alaskan Cod Liver Oil
Choose NOW for a lower cost per softgel and more EPA and DHA. Choose Sports Research for IFOS certification and a fish gelatin shell.
Nutritionist’s Note
If you take 2 softgels and a multivitamin, add up the vitamin A; most adults should stay well below 3,000 mcg a day from all supplements1.
Verdict: A low-cost, simple cod liver oil with balanced amounts of vitamins A and D.
#3Best Third-Party Certified
3. Sports Research Wild Alaskan Cod Liver Oil
BFN Score8.9/10
$$$Mid-range120 servings1 softgel per serving
Strongest atQuality & trustWeakest atEvidence fit
Sports Research is the only product on our list with IFOS certification, an independent program that tests fish oil for purity and freshness. It’s also MSC certified sustainable and uses a fish gelatin softgel.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- wild Alaskan cod liver oil
- Dose per serving
- 1 softgel – omega-3s 165 mg (EPA 60 mg, DHA 40 mg)
- Dose vs. research
- Below the roughly 250 mg EPA + DHA a day from seafood advice; the label allows up to 3 softgels3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 300 mcg (33% DV, 10% of the upper limit); vitamin D 10 mcg (50% DV)
- Purity testing
- IFOS certified; MSC certified sustainable
- Other ingredients
- softgel (tilapia gelatin, glycerin)
- Additives
- Clean
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod, tilapia)
Clinical Relevance
Independent testing matters for fish oils, which can oxidize or carry contaminants if poorly processed3. The vitamin A and D amounts are moderate, so even 3 softgels keep vitamin A at 30% of the upper limit1.
Strengths
- IFOS certified
- Fish gelatin, no beef
- Moderate vitamins A and D
Limitations
- Lowest EPA and DHA per softgel on our list
- Higher cost per gram of omega-3
- Smaller review base
Practical Details
Take 1 softgel a day with food; the label allows up to 3.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who want verified purity or avoid beef gelatin.
Not forpeople who want high omega-3 per softgel.
Buyer Experience
Buyers say it has no strange aftertaste and is easy to swallow, and several like that it avoids bovine gelatin.
The review base is still small, and a couple of buyers question the ingredient list.
vs. NOW Cod Liver Oil
Choose Sports Research for IFOS certification and a fish gelatin shell. Choose NOW for more EPA and DHA at a lower cost.
Nutritionist’s Note
IFOS tests the oil, not your total intake; the vitamin A math still applies if you take more than one softgel1.
Verdict: The best choice if independent purity testing is your top priority.
#4Best One-a-Day A & D
4. Carlson Cod Liver Oil Gems Super 1000 mg
BFN Score8.8/10
$$$Mid-range250 servings1 softgel per serving
Strongest atQuality & trustWeakest atPurity & additives
Carlson gives 250 mg of omega-3s, 600 mcg of vitamin A and 10 mcg of vitamin D in one softgel, from a long-established fish oil brand.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- cod liver oil, with retinyl palmitate added
- Dose per serving
- 1 softgel – omega-3s 250 mg (EPA 80 mg, DHA 100 mg)
- Dose vs. research
- Close to the roughly 250 mg omega-3 a day from seafood advice3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 600 mcg (67% DV, 20% of the upper limit); vitamin D 10 mcg (50% DV)
- Purity testing
- Not stated on the label
- Other ingredients
- softgel (bovine gelatin, glycerin), natural mixed tocopherols
- Additives
- Note – bovine gelatin
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod); not vegetarian
Clinical Relevance
One softgel gives a useful share of daily vitamins A and D12. The directions suggest 1 softgel twice a day; at that dose, vitamin A reaches 1,200 mcg, or 40% of the upper limit, before food or a multivitamin1.
Strengths
- Vitamins A and D in one softgel
- 250 softgels per bottle
- Long track record
Limitations
- Bovine gelatin
- Twice-daily directions double the vitamin A
- No outside certification on the label
Practical Details
Take 1 softgel a day with a meal. Stick with 1 if you also take a multivitamin.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who want vitamins A and D with omega-3 in one softgel.
Not foranyone already taking a vitamin A supplement.
Buyer Experience
Buyers praise the quality, say there is no fishy taste or burping, and find it good value for a large bottle. Many have used it for years.
A sizable minority object to the ingredient list, with some saying it contains soybean oil. The label we checked lists cod liver oil, gelatin, glycerin and mixed tocopherols.
vs. Nutricost Cod Liver Oil
Choose Carlson for more omega-3 and a brand with a long history. Choose Nutricost for a plainer softgel at a lower cost.
Nutritionist’s Note
Mixed tocopherols are a form of vitamin E added to keep the oil fresh; they are often made from soy but are highly refined.
Verdict: A reliable one-softgel source of omega-3s plus vitamins A and D.
#5Best Simple Formula
5. Nutricost Cod Liver Oil 1,000 mg
BFN Score8.6/10
$$$Budget120 servings1 softgel per serving
Strongest atDose & safetyWeakest atEvidence fit
Nutricost gives 1,000 mg of cod liver oil in a plain softgel, with 170 mg of EPA and DHA, 750 mcg of vitamin A and 6 mcg of vitamin D.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- cod liver oil
- Dose per serving
- 1 softgel – EPA 70 mg, DHA 100 mg
- Dose vs. research
- Below the roughly 250 mg EPA + DHA a day from seafood advice3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 750 mcg RAE (83% DV, 25% of the upper limit); vitamin D 6 mcg (30% DV)
- Purity testing
- Not stated (the brand says it is third-party tested)
- Other ingredients
- softgel (gelatin, glycerin, water)
- Additives
- Clean
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod); gluten-free, non-GMO
Clinical Relevance
One softgel nearly covers the daily vitamin A Daily Value, so this works best as your only vitamin A supplement1. Taking 2 a day for more omega-3 would bring vitamin A to half the upper limit.
Strengths
- Low cost per serving
- Short ingredient list
- One softgel per serving
Limitations
- Higher vitamin A per softgel
- Modest omega-3
- Gelatin source not stated
Practical Details
Take 1 softgel a day with a meal.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who want a basic cod liver oil at a low cost.
Not forpeople who also take a multivitamin with vitamin A.
Buyer Experience
Buyers rate the quality and value well, say it has a neutral taste and prevents fish burps, and several mention better hair.
Pill size gets mixed reviews, with several buyers finding the softgels very large.
vs. Carlson Cod Liver Oil Gems
Choose Nutricost for a lower cost and a plain softgel. Choose Carlson for more omega-3 and less vitamin A per softgel.
Nutritionist’s Note
Because one softgel provides 83% of the vitamin A Daily Value, check your multivitamin before adding this.
Verdict: A simple, low-cost cod liver oil for people who don’t take another vitamin A supplement.
#6Best High-Omega-3 Value
6. Micro Ingredients Cod Liver Oil 2,000 mg
BFN Score8.3/10
$$$Mid-range120 servings3 softgels per serving
Strongest atEvidence fitWeakest atDose & safety
Micro Ingredients gives 500 mg of omega-3s per serving at the lowest cost per gram of omega-3 we found, but a full serving also gives 1,600 mcg of vitamin A, more than half the upper limit.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- wild Arctic cod liver oil, with retinyl palmitate added
- Dose per serving
- 3 softgels – omega-3s 500 mg (EPA 216 mg, DHA 250 mg)
- Dose vs. research
- Nearly twice the roughly 250 mg EPA + DHA a day from seafood advice3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 1,600 mcg RAE (178% DV, about 53% of the upper limit); vitamin D about 16 mcg (80% DV)
- Purity testing
- Not stated (the brand says it is third-party tested)
- Other ingredients
- enteric-coated softgel, natural lemon oil
- Additives
- Flag – added retinyl palmitate pushes vitamin A above the Daily Value
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod)
Clinical Relevance
The omega-3 per serving is the second highest on our list3. The trade-off is vitamin A: a full serving plus a typical multivitamin can take you close to the 3,000 mcg upper limit1. Pregnant people should not use this product unless a doctor advises it.
Strengths
- Low cost per gram of omega-3
- 360 softgels per bottle
- Lemon oil and enteric coating to limit burps
Limitations
- High vitamin A per serving
- 3 softgels per serving
- Hard softgel texture bothers many buyers
Practical Details
Take 3 softgels a day with a meal, or take 1–2 if you also get vitamin A elsewhere.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who want more omega-3 for the money and take no other vitamin A.
Not forpregnant people or anyone on a multivitamin with vitamin A.
Buyer Experience
Buyers praise the quality and value, and like that there is no fishy aftertaste. Several notice softer skin or stronger nails.
Swallowing gets mixed reviews, and most buyers who mention texture describe the softgels as very hard. Some report throat irritation.
vs. Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil
Choose Micro Ingredients for a much lower cost per gram of omega-3. Choose Nordic Naturals for more EPA and DHA with about one-eighth of the vitamin A.
Nutritionist’s Note
Taking 1 softgel instead of 3 brings vitamin A down to about 533 mcg, a better fit if you also take a multivitamin1.
Verdict: Good omega-3 value, as long as you account for the high vitamin A.
#7Best Mini Softgel
7. Nature’s Craft Icelandic Cod Liver Oil
BFN Score8.2/10
$$$Mid-range120 servings2 softgels per serving
Strongest atPurity & additivesWeakest atDose & safety
Nature’s Craft uses small 500 mg softgels, so a 1,000 mg serving is easy to swallow. Two softgels give 1,500 mcg of vitamin A, half the upper limit, and 12.5 mcg of vitamin D.
Label Reality Check
- Active ingredient + form
- wild Icelandic cod liver oil, molecularly distilled, with retinyl palmitate added
- Dose per serving
- 2 softgels – omega-3s 240 mg (EPA 80 mg, DHA 100 mg)
- Dose vs. research
- Close to the roughly 250 mg omega-3 a day from seafood advice3
- % DV / Upper Limit
- vitamin A 1,500 mcg RAE (168% DV, 50% of the upper limit); vitamin D 12.5 mcg (63% DV)
- Purity testing
- ISO 17025 lab tested (the brand doesn’t name the lab)
- Other ingredients
- bovine gelatin, purified water, glycerin
- Additives
- Flag – added retinyl palmitate pushes vitamin A above the Daily Value
- Allergens & diet
- contains fish (cod); gluten-free; not vegetarian
Clinical Relevance
The small softgels make this the easiest product on our list to swallow. But the vitamin A is high for a 2-softgel serving, so one softgel a day is enough for most people who also eat a varied diet1.
Strengths
- Small, easy-to-swallow softgels
- Molecularly distilled oil
- Good vitamin D per serving
Limitations
- High vitamin A per serving
- Bovine gelatin
- Modest omega-3
Practical Details
Take 1–2 softgels a day with food, as the label directs.
Best For / Not For
Best forpeople who struggle with large softgels.
Not forpregnant people or anyone taking another vitamin A supplement.
Buyer Experience
Buyers love the small size and say the softgels are easy to swallow, gentle on the stomach and free of fish burps. Many mention joint comfort and value.
A small group still notices a fishy taste or mild stomach upset.
vs. Nutricost Cod Liver Oil
Choose Nature’s Craft for smaller softgels and more vitamin D. Choose Nutricost for a lower cost and less vitamin A per serving.
Nutritionist’s Note
If you take only one softgel a day, vitamin A drops to 750 mcg, which fits better alongside food and a multivitamin1.
Verdict: The easiest cod liver oil to swallow, best taken at one softgel a day.
Products We Didn’t Recommend
Carlson Cod Liver Oil Liquid. A well-made oil, but this guide covers softgels; Carlson’s Super 1000 mg softgel is on our list.
Nordic Naturals Pro Arctic Cod Liver Oil. A practitioner version of our top pick, with no clear advantage for most buyers.
21st Century Norwegian Cod Liver Oil. Only 400 mg of oil per softgel, so you need more softgels for the same omega-3.
Other sizes of our picks. NOW, Carlson and Nature’s Craft also sell smaller bottles of the same formulas; we list one size per brand.
Evidence Scorecard
| Use | What it’s studied for | Evidence level | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vitamin D status | Raising low vitamin D levels | Strong | Vitamin D supplements reliably raise blood levels2 |
| High triglycerides | Lowering triglycerides | Strong (at 2–4 g omega-3) | Doses used in studies are far above what cod liver oil can safely give4 |
| Heart attack prevention | Major cardiovascular events | Not supported in healthy adults | Large trials found no overall reduction3 |
| Joint pain (rheumatoid arthritis) | Pain and stiffness | Limited | Some benefit with fish oil; cod liver oil data are small3 |
| Eye and brain health | Dry eye, memory | Limited or not supported | Mixed results for omega-3 supplements3 |
Cod liver oil is best seen as a modest source of omega-3s and vitamins A and D, not a high-dose omega-3 treatment.
How to Take Cod Liver Oil for Best Results
| Step | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Daily amount | Follow the label, usually 1–3 softgels | Keeps vitamin A in a safe range1 |
| Check vitamin A | Add up vitamin A from all supplements | Stay well below 3,000 mcg a day1 |
| Timing | Take with a meal that contains fat | Improves absorption of omega-3s and vitamins A and D23 |
| Fish burps | Freeze the softgels or take them at the start of a meal | Slows release in the stomach |
| Storage | Keep cool and away from light | Limits oxidation of the oil3 |
- Don’t double up with a multivitamin high in vitamin A without checking the total1.
- Need more omega-3? Add a regular fish oil rather than more cod liver oil.
- Stop and see a doctor if you get headaches, nausea, blurred vision or bone pain.
What to Expect and When
Blood omega-3 levels rise over a few weeks of daily use3. Vitamin D levels take a few months of steady use to settle at a new level.
Most people won’t feel a difference quickly. Judge it by a blood test or over a few months, not a few days.
Safety, Side Effects & Drug Interactions
Fishy aftertaste, burping, heartburn and loose stools are the most common side effects3. The bigger risk with cod liver oil is too much vitamin A over time, which can cause liver damage, bone loss and birth defects1.
| Medication or condition | Possible interaction | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Warfarin and other blood thinners | High omega-3 intake may increase bleeding3 | Ask your doctor; keep the dose steady |
| Retinoids (isotretinoin, acitretin) | Added vitamin A raises toxicity risk1 | Avoid unless your doctor approves |
| Orlistat | Can lower absorption of vitamins A and D12 | Take them at least 2 hours apart |
| Pregnancy or trying to conceive | Preformed vitamin A can cause birth defects1 | Ask your doctor; choose a low-vitamin A option |
| Liver disease | Vitamin A is stored in the liver1 | Ask your doctor first |
| Fish allergy | Allergic reaction | Avoid |
Food First: Where Else to Get These Nutrients
| Food | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| Salmon, sardines, herring and mackerel | Rich in EPA, DHA and vitamin D23 |
| Eggs and fortified milk | Contain vitamin D2 |
| Liver | Very high in vitamin A; limit it if you take cod liver oil1 |
| Carrots, sweet potatoes and leafy greens | Beta-carotene, which the body turns into vitamin A as needed1 |
| Walnuts, flaxseed and chia | ALA, a plant omega-3 the body converts only partly to EPA and DHA3 |
Two servings of oily fish a week give more EPA and DHA than most cod liver oil softgels, without the vitamin A.
How to Choose a Cod Liver Oil Supplement
Vitamin A per Serving
Check mcg RAE per serving and compare it with the 3,000 mcg upper limit. Lower is safer if you take a multivitamin.
Added Retinyl Palmitate
Some products add synthetic vitamin A to reach a higher number. Natural cod liver oil levels are usually lower.
EPA and DHA
Look at EPA plus DHA, not the “1,000 mg” on the front, which is the total oil.
Vitamin D
Amounts vary from almost none to over 15 mcg. Pick based on whether you already take vitamin D.
Testing
IFOS certification or published certificates of analysis show the oil was tested for freshness and contaminants.
Softgel Size and Shell
Mini softgels help if you struggle to swallow. Fish gelatin avoids beef.
Label Red Flags
- Vitamin A above 100% DV per serving with no warning about other sources
- Only “cod liver oil 1,000 mg” listed, without EPA and DHA amounts
- Claims that cod liver oil treats arthritis, infections or other diseases
- No vitamin A or D amounts on the label
Important: These supplements are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Results vary by individual. If you have a health condition or take medications, check with your doctor before adding any new supplement to your routine.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best cod liver oil capsules?
Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil is our top pick for its high EPA and DHA with low vitamin A. On a budget, choose NOW Cod Liver Oil; for third-party certification, choose Sports Research.
Are cod liver oil capsules better than liquid?
They contain the same oil. Capsules avoid the taste and are easier to measure; liquid gives more oil per dose at a lower cost.
How many cod liver oil capsules should I take a day?
Follow the label, usually 1–3 softgels. Check the vitamin A per softgel and keep your total from all supplements well below 3,000 mcg a day1.
Is cod liver oil the same as fish oil?
No. Fish oil comes from the body of oily fish and has little vitamin A or D. Cod liver oil comes from the liver and contains both vitamins, but usually less omega-3 per softgel3.
Can I take cod liver oil while pregnant?
Ask your doctor first. Too much preformed vitamin A can cause birth defects, so a low-vitamin A product or a regular fish oil is usually safer1.
Can I take cod liver oil and vitamin D together?
Yes, but add them up. The adult upper limit for vitamin D is 100 mcg (4,000 IU) a day2.
Final Verdict
Nordic Naturals Arctic Cod Liver Oil is the best cod liver oil capsule for most people: the most EPA and DHA on our list with the least vitamin A.
On a budget, choose NOW Cod Liver Oil. For verified purity, choose Sports Research. If large pills are a problem, choose Nature’s Craft and take one softgel a day.
Whatever you choose, count the vitamin A from all your supplements, and talk to your doctor if you’re pregnant, take a blood thinner or have liver disease.
Sources & History
References
- Vitamin A and Carotenoids: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals — NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
- Vitamin D: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals — NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals — NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids for the Management of Hypertriglyceridemia: A Science Advisory From the American Heart Association — Circulation, 2019
Update history
- Moved to BFN Score v3: screened 16 cod liver oil softgels and ranked seven by EPA and DHA, vitamin A against the upper limit, vitamin D, testing, other ingredients and cost; expanded from 4 to 7 picks; added a table showing how many softgels reach the vitamin A upper limit; removed fixed prices; added an evidence scorecard and safety table.







