At a Glance
- Research track record Montmorency is the most commonly grown tart cherry in the US and the variety used in many published tart cherry trials.
- Anthocyanins Balaton, another tart cherry, had about 2.4–6 times more anthocyanins than Montmorency in lab analyses.
- Melatonin Montmorency had about 6 times more melatonin than Balaton, though both amounts are tiny.
- Processing matters too Juice concentrate, dried cherries and powders made from the same Montmorency fruit had 26–77% fewer polyphenols than frozen whole cherries.
- Best capsule for most people Zazzee USDA Organic Tart Cherry – 300 mg of organic 10:1 extract in one capsule (variety not stated on the label).
The Short Answer: The variety matters a little, but not in a simple “Montmorency is better” way. Montmorency has the research behind it: it’s the most commonly grown tart cherry in the US4, and many recovery trials used Montmorency juice or powder78. But Balaton, another tart cherry, had about 6 times more anthocyanins in one analysis1 and about 2.4 times more in another2. Montmorency, in turn, had about 6 times more melatonin3.
On this page
We didn’t find a human trial comparing the varieties directly. For a supplement, the dose, how it was processed and whether the label states its active compounds tell you more than the variety name.
Shopping for a supplement? Our guide to the best tart cherry supplements compares 8 capsules and powders, including which labels name the variety.
Montmorency vs Balaton vs Sweet Cherries
There’s no official category called “regular tart cherry.” Montmorency is itself a tart cherry, also called a sour cherry (Prunus cerasus). The useful comparison is with other tart cherry varieties, such as Balaton, and with sweet cherries (Prunus avium), a different species.
| Montmorency (tart) | Balaton (tart) | Sweet cherries (e.g., Bing) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Species | Prunus cerasus | Prunus cerasus | Prunus avium |
| How it’s used | Most commonly grown tart cherry in the US; nearly all tart cherries are processed4 | Less commonly grown in the US than Montmorency4 | Mostly eaten fresh4 |
| Anthocyanins | Lowest of six tart cherries in one study: 33 μg/g2 | About 6 times Montmorency1; 79 μg/g in another study2 | Generally higher than tart cherries4 |
| Total phenolics | Higher than Bing in flesh, pits and skin4 | Not compared here | Lower than Montmorency4 |
| Melatonin | 13.5 ng/g3 | 2.1 ng/g3 | 10–20 ng/g in two varieties tested4 |
| Human trials | Used in many published trials, including recovery trials78 | We found no published trials using Balaton specifically | Studied separately; not interchangeable with tart cherry trials |
Why Montmorency Dominates the Research
Montmorency is the most commonly grown tart cherry in the US4, and about 97% of tart cherries are processed rather than sold fresh, mainly for cooking and baking4. That helps explain why so much tart cherry research uses it.
Several key trials name Montmorency in their titles, including a strength recovery trial using Montmorency juice concentrate7 and a half-marathon trial using powdered Montmorency tart cherry capsules8. So much of the evidence for “tart cherry” is really evidence about Montmorency products.
That’s a research track record, not proof that Montmorency works better than other tart cherries. We didn’t find a published trial that compared Montmorency with Balaton or another variety head to head.
Anthocyanins: Balaton Has More
Anthocyanins are the red pigments in cherries and one of the main groups of polyphenols they contain.
- Wang 1997: Balaton and Montmorency contain the same three anthocyanins, all forms of cyanidin, but Balaton had about 6 times more1.
- Siddiq 2011: In six tart cherry selections grown in Michigan, Montmorency had the lowest total anthocyanins (33 μg/g). Balaton had 79 μg/g, and a newer breeding selection had 391 μg/g, about 12 times Montmorency2.
Higher pigment didn’t translate into much higher antioxidant capacity in the lab. Balaton’s ORAC value was 97% of Montmorency’s, though several newer selections scored up to 45% higher2. And lab values don’t tell you what happens in your body: we didn’t find any human trial comparing these varieties.
Melatonin: Montmorency Has More
Montmorency cherries contained about 13.5 nanograms of melatonin per gram, compared with about 2.1 ng/g in Balaton, roughly 6 times more3.
Both amounts are very small compared with a melatonin supplement. Our guide to tart cherry for sleep explains why tart cherry’s sleep effects may not come from melatonin alone.
Processing Matters as Much as Variety
Even within Montmorency, the form makes a big difference. A 2025 analysis of five Montmorency products found frozen raw cherries had the most total polyphenols. Compared with frozen fruit, the other forms had fewer5:
| Montmorency product | Total polyphenols vs. frozen raw fruit |
|---|---|
| Juice concentrate | 26% lower |
| Unsweetened dried cherries | 40% lower |
| Freeze-dried powder | 60% lower |
| Sweetened dried cherries | 77% lower |
The mix of compounds changed too. Anthocyanins made up 18% of the polyphenols in frozen raw cherries, but less in the processed products5.
Supplements vary widely too. A review of 43 tart cherry studies found the products used provided 143–2,140 mg of polyphenols and 15–547 mg of anthocyanins a day, and only 20 of the studies analyzed the actual product they used6. That’s why a well-made extract from a less-studied variety could provide more active compounds than a heavily processed Montmorency product.
Our Top Tart Cherry Pick
Zazzee USDA Organic Tart Cherry
300 mg per capsule1 capsule a dayUSDA Organic
If you want a simple, clean tart cherry capsule, this is our top pick. Each capsule gives 300 mg of organic 10:1 extract with no sweeteners, and it ranked #1 (BFN Score 9.6) in our guide to the best tart cherry supplements. Keep in mind that the label lists tart cherry (Prunus cerasus) without naming the variety. If Montmorency on the label matters to you, see which of our 8 picks states it.
How to Read a Tart Cherry Label
Most tart cherry supplement labels list only the species, Prunus cerasus, without naming the variety. In our comparison of 8 tart cherry supplements, only one label named Montmorency. That doesn’t mean the others aren’t Montmorency, but you can’t confirm it.
These details tell you more than the variety name:
- Anthocyanin or polyphenol content: the most useful number for comparing products, when it’s stated.
- Extract ratio and serving size: shows how concentrated the extract is and how much you get per day.
- Third-party testing: confirms that what’s on the label is in the bottle.
- Other ingredients: check for added sugar in juices and concentrates, and fillers in capsules.
Our guide to how much tart cherry extract to take daily compares common capsule doses with research doses, and tart cherry juice vs. capsules explains the trade-offs between forms.
Should You Pay More for Montmorency?
Choose Montmorency if you want to match the variety used in many published trials. That’s a reasonable default, especially for sleep or exercise recovery.
Don’t rule out a product just because it doesn’t name the variety, or uses another tart cherry. If it states its anthocyanin content, gives a clear extract dose and is third-party tested, it may tell you more than a Montmorency label that discloses nothing else.
Don’t assume sweet cherries will work like tart cherries. They’re a different species with a different mix of compounds4, and they weren’t what the tart cherry trials tested.
Safety
Safety concerns depend on the form more than the variety:
- Sugar: one cup of tart cherry juice from concentrate has about 25 g of natural sugar9.
- Potassium: a cup of juice has about 400 mg9, which matters if you have kidney disease.
- Medicines: if you take blood thinners or other prescription medicines, check with your doctor or pharmacist before adding a supplement.
Our guide to tart cherry extract side effects covers who should be careful and why.
Final Verdict
Montmorency isn’t clearly better than other tart cherries, but it’s the variety with the research behind it. Balaton contains more anthocyanins, Montmorency contains more melatonin, and we found no trial comparing them in people. How a product is processed changes its polyphenol content as much as the variety does.
For most people, the dose, form and what the label discloses matter more than the variety name. If you want a simple capsule, Zazzee USDA Organic Tart Cherry gives 300 mg of organic 10:1 extract in one capsule, though its label doesn’t name the variety. If Montmorency on the label matters to you, our guide to the best tart cherry supplements shows which pick states it.
Important: This guide is for general information and isn’t medical advice. Talk to your doctor before taking tart cherry if you have diabetes or kidney disease, or take prescription medicines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Montmorency tart cherry better than other tart cherries?
What’s the difference between Montmorency and Balaton cherries?
Are Montmorency cherries the same as sour cherries?
Yes. Montmorency is a variety of sour cherry, also called tart cherry (Prunus cerasus)4.
Do sweet cherries work like tart cherries?
Not necessarily. Sweet cherries are a different species. They generally have more anthocyanins but fewer total phenolics than Montmorency4, and they weren’t used in the tart cherry trials.
Which tart cherry has the most melatonin?
In a direct comparison, Montmorency had about 13.5 ng/g and Balaton about 2.1 ng/g3. Both are tiny amounts compared with a melatonin supplement.
Does processing affect tart cherry nutrients?
Yes. Montmorency juice concentrate had 26% fewer polyphenols than frozen raw cherries, and sweetened dried cherries had 77% fewer5.
How do I know if a supplement uses Montmorency?
Check the label for the variety name. Most labels list only Prunus cerasus. If the variety isn’t named, look for a stated anthocyanin content and third-party testing instead.
Sources & History
References
- Quantification and Characterization of Anthocyanins in Balaton Tart Cherries — Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 1997
- Characterization of New Tart Cherry (Prunus cerasus L.) Selections Based on Fruit Quality, Total Anthocyanins, and Antioxidant Capacity — International Journal of Food Properties, 2011
- Detection and Quantification of the Antioxidant Melatonin in Montmorency and Balaton Tart Cherries — Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2001
- A Review of the Health Benefits of Cherries — Nutrients, 2018
- A Comprehensive Polyphenolic Characterization of Five Montmorency Tart Cherry (Prunus cerasus L.) Product Formulations — Foods, 2025
- Review of Analytical Methods and Reporting of the Polyphenol Content of Tart Cherry Supplements in Human Supplementation Studies — Frontiers in Nutrition, 2021
- Montmorency Cherry Juice Reduces Muscle Damage Caused by Intensive Strength Exercise — Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2011
- Effects of Powdered Montmorency Tart Cherry Supplementation on Acute Endurance Exercise Performance in Aerobically Trained Individuals — Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2016
- Juice, Tart Cherry, from Concentrate, Shelf-Stable (FDC ID 2727589) — USDA FoodData Central
Update history
- Rewrote with a comparison table of Montmorency, Balaton and sweet cherries; added anthocyanin and antioxidant data from a study of six tart cherry selections and polyphenol data for five Montmorency products; corrected melatonin (the cited study found more melatonin in Montmorency, not Balaton) and removed an unsourced claim that a later study disagreed; replaced a ResearchGate link with the original journal source. October 5, 2026 – Previous version.









